Table of Contents
Introduction: The Phone Call I’ll Never Forget
Early in my career as an insurance litigator, I received a phone call that I will never forget.
It was from the senior partner of a small, brilliant architectural firm.
They were facing a multi-million dollar lawsuit over an alleged design flaw in a commercial building.
It was a “bet the company” case, the kind that keeps you awake at night.
But they weren’t panicked; they had a top-tier professional liability insurance policy.
They had done everything right—or so they thought.
Their claim was denied.
The denial letter wasn’t about a technical exclusion or an inadequate policy limit.
It was about timing.
They had received a formal demand letter from the building’s owner—an event that constituted a “claim” under their policy—but they had spent a month consulting with their own engineers before notifying their insurance carrier.
By the time they submitted the claim, they were 45 days past the date the claim was made against them.
Their policy was a “claims-made and reported” policy, and they had missed the strict reporting window by a few weeks.
That single, seemingly small administrative delay cost them everything.
Their business did not survive the lawsuit.
That professional catastrophe became my professional epiphany.
It taught me that an insurance policy is not a passive safety net waiting to catch you.
It is a complex, active mechanism with a critical timing component, much like a fine Swiss watch.
And the most important, yet most misunderstood, component of that mechanism is the insured’s duty to report.
This report will deconstruct that mechanism, clarifying the crucial difference between being the “insured” and acting as the “reporter,” and provide a framework for ensuring your safety net actually works when you need it most.
Part 1: The Cast of Characters – Defining “The Insured”
Before analyzing the duties of an insured, it is essential to establish precisely who they are.
An insurance policy is a legal contract that defines a specific cast of characters, each with distinct rights and responsibilities.1
Misunderstanding one’s role in this cast can lead to critical gaps in coverage.
An “insured” is broadly defined as any person or organization whose life, health, or property is covered by the policy.3
However, this general definition contains a crucial hierarchy of roles.
The Named Insured – The Owner of the Policy
The most important character is the “Named Insured.” This is the individual or entity specifically listed on the policy’s declarations page—the party referred to as “you” in the contract language.1
The Named Insured is the owner of the policy.
They are responsible for paying the premiums and are the only party with the authority to make changes, add endorsements, or cancel the policy.6
Crucially, the Named Insured also bears the primary responsibility for fulfilling the policy’s conditions, including the fundamental duty to report claims.6
The legal structure of the Named Insured must be precise.
For a sole proprietorship, the individual owner should be the Named Insured, not just the business’s trade name.
For a corporation or LLC, the legal entity itself must be the Named Insured.7
An error in this designation can create significant coverage issues down the line.
The “Other” Insureds – Expanding the Circle of Protection
Coverage often extends beyond the Named Insured to other individuals, but this protection is conditional.
General liability and professional liability policies typically include company employees, executives, and sometimes even volunteers as “insureds,” but only while they are performing their duties on behalf of the Named Insured.9
For example, an employee who causes property damage while on a job site is likely covered by their employer’s general liability policy.
However, that same employee would not be covered for an incident that occurs in their personal time.10
This distinction is vital for understanding the scope and limits of a business’s liability protection.
The Additional Insured – A Strategic Extension of Coverage
An “Additional Insured” is a person or entity added to the policy by an endorsement, often to satisfy a contractual requirement.11
For instance, a general contractor may require all subcontractors to add the contractor to their policies as an Additional Insured.
This status grants the additional party coverage under the policy, but they do not possess the rights of a Named Insured.
They cannot modify or cancel the policy and are not responsible for premium payments.6
Their rights are limited, providing a layer of protection without ceding control of the policy.
This hierarchy of insureds—Named, Other, and Additional—is not merely a set of definitions; it establishes a framework of control and obligation.
The ultimate responsibility for policy compliance, particularly the duty to report a claim, almost always rests with the Named Insured.
An employee (an “other insured”) might receive an angry email from a client that constitutes a potential claim, but if that employee fails to escalate the information to company leadership (the “Named Insured”) so a timely report can be made to the insurer, the entire organization could find its coverage voided.
This highlights a critical operational risk: the internal flow of information within an insured organization is a direct component of its insurance protection.
Part 2: Solving the “Reporter” Riddle
The common query of “reporter vs insured” points to a fundamental confusion in terminology.
The word “reporter” carries several meanings in legal and regulatory contexts, but only one is central to the function of a liability insurance policy.
Clarifying this term is essential to understanding your contractual duties.
The Red Herrings – Common but Incorrect Meanings
To avoid confusion, it is useful to first set aside other common uses of the term “reporter.”
- Court Reporter: This is a certified professional responsible for creating a verbatim official record of legal proceedings, such as depositions or trials.12 Their transcripts are crucial for litigation, and they may even carry their own professional liability insurance.15 However, their role is to document the legal process, not to report a claim to an insurer.
- Mandated Reporter: This term refers to individuals, often in professions like teaching, healthcare, or social work, who are legally obligated by statute to report suspected cases of abuse or neglect to the appropriate authorities.17 This is a civic and legal duty entirely separate from the contractual obligations within an insurance policy.
While these are important roles, they are not what an insurance policy refers to when it discusses the reporting of a claim.
The True Meaning – The Insured as the Reporter of a Claim
In the world of liability insurance, the most critical definition of “reporter” is not a job title but a function.
The “reporter” is the Named Insured fulfilling their contractual duty to provide timely notice of a claim or potential claim to the insurance company.19
This act of reporting is the trigger that activates the policy’s coverage mechanism.
The policy language does not speak of a “reporter” as a distinct entity but relentlessly details the
action of reporting that must be performed by the insured.19
The initial query, “reporter vs insured,” is therefore based on a false premise.
The terms are not in opposition.
The relationship is one of identity and action: the Insured (the identity) must perform the function of a Reporter (the action) to receive the benefits of the policy.
The failure to connect this identity to this function is the root cause of countless preventable claim denials.
Part 3: The Epiphany – Your Policy as a Clockwork Mechanism
To truly grasp the gravity of the reporting duty, it is helpful to move beyond legal jargon and use an analogy.
Think of your insurance policy not as a static document filed away in a cabinet, but as a fine Swiss watch—a complex clockwork mechanism designed to perform a specific function at a critical moment.
- The Mainspring: You, the Insured, are the mainspring. The premiums you pay are the energy that winds the mechanism, giving it the potential to act. Without this stored energy, nothing can happen.
- The Chime: A Claim made against you—a lawsuit, a demand letter, an accusation of wrongdoing—is the event the clock is designed to announce. This is the moment you need the mechanism to work, to sound the alarm and summon the resources for your defense.
- The Escapement Wheel: The Act of Reporting the claim to your insurer is the escapement wheel. In a mechanical watch, the escapement is a tiny, precise, and unforgiving component that controls the release of energy from the mainspring, allowing the hands to move forward at a regulated pace. It controls the timing. If the escapement wheel is misaligned or fails to engage at the right moment, the clock’s hands will not move, and the chime will never sound—no matter how tightly the mainspring is wound. The entire mechanism fails.
This framework demonstrates that reporting is not a mere administrative step; it is the fundamental trigger that allows the transfer of risk from you to the insurer.
A late report is a failed escapement.
The potential energy of years of premium payments is never released, and you are left to face the consequences of the claim alone.
Part 4: The Two Clocks – A Deep Dive into “Claims-Made” vs. “Claims-Made and Reported” Policies
Not all policy mechanisms are built the same.
In the realm of professional liability insurance, which covers fields like law, architecture, consulting, and technology, the two most common designs are “claims-made” and “claims-made and reported”.21
The difference between them lies entirely in the design of their “escapement wheel”—the reporting requirement.
The “Claims-Made” Clock – A Flexible Escapement
A “claims-made” policy is triggered when a claim is first made against you during the policy period.19
The reporting requirement for this type of policy is more flexible.
The policy language often requires the insured to report the claim “as soon as practicable”.19
This phrasing can, in some circumstances, allow for a claim made late in the policy period to be reported shortly after the policy has expired and still be covered.19
For example, if a lawsuit is filed against an insured two days before their policy expires, a court may find that reporting it a week later (after the policy has expired) still qualifies as “as soon as practicable”.20
The “Claims-Made and Reported” Clock – A Rigid, Unforgiving Escapement
This is the policy type that led to the demise of the architectural firm in the introduction.
It is a dual-trigger mechanism that is far more restrictive.
For coverage to exist, the claim must be both made against you AND reported to the insurer during the same policy period.20
Many of these policies include a short, contractually defined grace period (typically 30 or 60 days) after the policy period ends for reporting claims that were made during the policy period, but this is a hard deadline.22
A day late truly is a dollar short—all the dollars.
This form is less expensive precisely because it shifts a significant timing risk back onto the policyholder.20
Identifying Your Policy – Don’t Be Fooled
A critical danger for policyholders is that many policies are labeled simply as “Claims-Made” on the declarations page but contain the highly restrictive “Claims-Made and Reported” language deep within the policy’s terms and conditions.19
The only way to know which type of clock you truly own is to read the “Notice of Claim,” “Reporting,” or similarly titled section of your policy.
This section will contain the specific language that governs your reporting duties.22
| Feature | Claims-Made Policy | Claims-Made and Reported Policy |
| Coverage Trigger | (1) Claim is made against the insured during the policy period. | (1) Claim is made against the insured AND (2) Claim is reported to the insurer during the policy period. |
| Reporting Requirement | “As soon as practicable,” which may extend beyond the policy period. | A strict deadline, typically within the policy period or a short, defined grace period (e.g., 30-60 days). |
| Key Risk to Insured | The insurer may dispute whether the report was made “as soon as practicable.” | Missing the hard reporting deadline results in a complete and total loss of coverage for the claim. |
| Typical Cost | Generally more expensive. | Generally less expensive. |
| Analogy | The Flexible Escapement | The Rigid Escapement |
Part 5: Winding the Clock Correctly – A Practical Guide to Fulfilling Your Duty to Report
Understanding the theory is one thing; applying it under the pressure of a potential lawsuit is another.
This section provides an actionable guide for professionals to manage their reporting duties effectively and avoid common, costly mistakes.
What Constitutes a “Claim”? It’s Broader Than a Lawsuit
A “claim” is not just the moment you are served with a lawsuit.
Policy definitions are often much broader.
A claim can be a written demand for money or services, or even an act or omission that an insured reasonably believes will result in such a demand.20
A real-world example involved an employee who filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).
The company did not report this to their insurer.
A year later, the employee filed a lawsuit based on the same facts.
The insurer denied coverage for the lawsuit because the initial EEOC complaint met the policy’s definition of a “claim,” and it was not reported during the policy period in which it was received.27
Recognizing a “claim” at its earliest stage is the first step to timely reporting.
The Power of Reporting “Circumstances”
Most professional liability policies contain a powerful, proactive tool: the ability to report a “circumstance” or “potential claim”.26
If an insured becomes aware of a situation that could reasonably be expected to give rise to a future claim—for example, a client expresses extreme dissatisfaction with a project and alludes to financial damages—they can provide written notice of this circumstance to the insurer.
If this notice is properly filed during the policy period, any future claim that arises from that specific circumstance will be deemed to have been made on the date the circumstance was first reported, even if the formal lawsuit comes years later.26
This effectively locks in coverage under the current policy and is a crucial risk management strategy.
Common Mistakes That Break the Mechanism
Based on analysis of claim disputes, several common errors can lead to a denial of coverage:
- Delaying Notification: This is the most frequent and fatal error, especially with “claims-made and reported” policies. Waiting to see if a problem resolves itself is a gamble that can void coverage entirely.29
- Poor Documentation: Failing to preserve evidence, take photos, and keep detailed records can weaken your claim, as the insurer relies on your records to investigate and settle.29
- Admitting Fault: Never admit fault or liability for an incident. Most policies have a cooperation clause that prohibits the insured from assuming any obligation without the insurer’s consent. Admitting fault can breach this clause and lead to a denial of coverage.29
- Providing Incomplete Information: Submitting a notice with inaccurate dates or a vague description of the incident can cause delays or create grounds for the insurer to question the claim.30
- Not Understanding the Policy: The most fundamental mistake is failing to read the policy to understand what is covered, what is excluded, and what your specific duties are in the event of a claim.29
Effectively managing an insurance policy is not a passive activity but an active process.
The provision allowing the reporting of a “circumstance” transforms the policy from a purely reactive tool into a proactive one.
Professionals who understand this can strategically manage their liability exposure, tagging potential future liabilities and assigning them to a current policy period.
This elevates the role of the insured from a mere policyholder to an active risk manager.
Part 6: When the Clock Breaks – Claim Denials, Legal Battles, and the Notice-Prejudice Rule
When a report is late, the consequences can be severe.
Understanding the legal fallout is critical for appreciating the stakes involved in timely reporting.
Case Studies in Denial
Real-world examples illustrate the unforgiving nature of reporting deadlines.
In one case, a construction subcontractor was sued by a general contractor but did not notify its insurer until 10 months after its “claims-made-and-reported” policy had expired.
After a consent judgment of $5.7 million was entered against the subcontractor, the court ruled that the insurer owed nothing because the claim was not reported within the policy period.
The failure to report was a complete bar to coverage.33
The EEOC case mentioned earlier is another stark example of how failing to recognize and report an early-stage “claim” can nullify coverage for a later, more serious lawsuit.27
The “Notice-Prejudice” Rule – A Potential Lifeline
In many jurisdictions, a legal doctrine known as the “notice-prejudice rule” offers some protection to policyholders.
This rule, which can be established by state statute or court decisions, generally states that an insurer cannot deny a claim based on late notice unless it can prove that the delay actually harmed, or “prejudiced,” its ability to adequately investigate and defend the claim.34
The purpose is to prevent insurers from using a minor procedural delay as a technicality to escape a valid coverage obligation.35
This rule often applies to “occurrence” policies and can sometimes apply to standard “claims-made” policies.
The Crucial, Devastating Exception
This brings us to the legal climax of this analysis.
The vast majority of courts have ruled that the notice-prejudice rule does not apply to “claims-made and reported” policies.34
The legal reasoning is that the reporting deadline in these policies is not merely a procedural condition; it is a fundamental part of the insuring agreement that
defines the scope of coverage itself.34
In this legal view, reporting a claim outside the policy period is not considered “late notice.” It is viewed as a complete failure to trigger coverage in the first place.
The escapement wheel never engaged, so the mechanism never activated.
To force an insurer to cover such a claim, courts reason, would be to rewrite a fundamental term of the contract and compel the insurer to provide coverage for a risk it never agreed to assume.33
This legal interpretation validates the economic model of “claims-made and reported” policies.
These policies are less expensive because the hard reporting deadline provides the insurer with actuarial certainty.
Once the reporting window for a given policy year closes, the insurer can confidently close its books on that year’s potential losses.37
By refusing to apply the notice-prejudice rule, the legal system upholds this model.
It places the full and final responsibility for timely reporting squarely on the insured.
In effect, the insured is not just buying protection; they are buying a lower premium in exchange for accepting a significant and unforgiving timing risk.
Conclusion: Becoming the Master of Your Own Clock
The journey from the architectural firm’s tragic phone call to this legal conclusion reveals a set of core principles.
The insured must also be the reporter.
The act of reporting is the escapement wheel that makes the entire policy mechanism function.
The distinction between a “claims-made” and a “claims-made and reported” policy is the difference between a flexible timing mechanism and a rigid one, and the courts will not save you from the consequences of the latter.
You are now armed with the knowledge to be the master of your own policy.
This knowledge is not passive; it demands action.
The final call to action is a three-step process:
- Identify: Locate your professional and general liability policies immediately. Find the “Notice of Claim” or “Reporting” section and read it carefully. Determine, with certainty, which clock you own—the flexible “claims-made” or the rigid “claims-made and reported.”
- Systematize: Create a clear, written internal procedure for your organization. This procedure must dictate how any potential claim or circumstance—from a client’s angry email to a formal demand letter—is immediately escalated to the person or department responsible for notifying your insurer.
- Communicate: Discuss this procedure with your key employees and your insurance broker. Ensure everyone understands the stakes and their role in protecting the company.
The architectural firm failed not because of a lack of talent or a poor business plan, but because of a lack of knowledge about one crucial clause buried in their insurance contract.
By understanding the principles in this report, you have gained the knowledge that could one day save your own business.
Their story serves as a stark warning, but it can also be your source of empowerment.
Works cited
- Understanding Your Insurance Policy | Department of Insurance, SC – Official Website, accessed August 16, 2025, https://doi.sc.gov/957/Understanding-Your-Insurance-Policy
- What Is Insurance? – Investopedia, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/insurance.asp
- www.law.cornell.edu, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/insured#:~:text=An%20insured%20is%20a%20person,covered%20by%20an%20insurance%20policy.
- insured | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/insured
- Named Insured vs. Additional Insured: What’s the Difference? – Wade Associates, accessed August 16, 2025, https://wadeict.com/blog/named-insured-vs-additional-insured-whats-the-difference/
- What is a named insured? – Kin Insurance, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.kin.com/blog/named-insured/
- Who Should be the Named Insured on Commercial Insurance Policies?, accessed August 16, 2025, https://coterieinsurance.com/blog/who-should-be-the-named-insured-on-commercial-insurance-policies/
- Name of Insured Meaning & Definition – Founder Shield, accessed August 16, 2025, https://foundershield.com/insurance-terms/definition/name-of-insured/
- What is an Insured? Definition and Meaning of Insured | NEXT, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.nextinsurance.com/glossary/insured/
- What Is an Insured in Business Insurance? – Insureon, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.insureon.com/insurance-glossary/insured
- Exactly Who is Insured Under Your Insurance Policy? – Larkin Hoffman, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.larkinhoffman.com/real-estate-construction-blog/exactly-who-is-insured-under-your-insurance-policy
- Understanding the Role of Court Reporters in Insurance Disputes – Compex Legal Services, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.compexlegal.com/blog/understanding-the-role-of-court-reporters-in-insurance-disputes
- www.sjcourts.org, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.sjcourts.org/general-info/court-reporter-information/#:~:text=Court%20reporters%20make%20a%20verbatim,upon%20request%20of%20the%20parties.
- Court Reporter Information – Superior Court of CA – County of San Joaquin, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.sjcourts.org/general-info/court-reporter-information/
- Court Reporters Liability Insurance – Proliability, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.proliability.com/professional-liability-insurance/court-reporters.html
- Liability and Errors & Omission Insurance – California Court Reporters Association, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.cal-ccra.org/ccra-errors-omissions-insurance
- Reporter Definition: 451 Samples | Law Insider, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/reporter
- Mandated Reporter Responsibilities – Hanover Insurance, accessed August 16, 2025, https://sites.hanover.com/linec/docs/171-0817.pdf
- Claims Made vs Claims Made and Reported – Insurance Training Center, accessed August 16, 2025, https://insurancetrainingcenter.com/resource/claims-made-vs-claims-made-and-reported/
- Claims Made Versus Claims Made and Reported Policies | Insurance Center of North Jersey | Maywood, NJ, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.icnj.com/blog/claims-made-versus-claims-made-and-reported-policies/
- Claims Made and Claims Made versus Reported Coverage Forms, accessed August 16, 2025, https://rms.iiaba.net/Resources/Pages/Publications/Articles/claims-made-article.pdf
- Claims-Made vs. Claims-Made and Reported – Hausmann Group, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.myhaus.com/blog/claims-made-vs.-claims-made-and-reported
- Claims-made, Claims-made and Reported, Wrongful Act, and Occurrence Policies | Young Moore, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.youngmoorelaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/WEB-Claims-made-cliams-made-and-reported-wrongful-act-and-occurrence-policies.pdf
- Professional Liability Insurance Frequently Asked Questions, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.thehartford.com/professional-liability-insurance/faq
- Claims-made, Claims-made and Reported, Wrongful Act, and Occurrence Policies – Young Moore Attorneys, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.youngmoorelaw.com/blog/claims-made-claims-made-and-reported-wrongful-act-and-occurrence-policies/
- Understanding claims made & reported in professional liability policies, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.berkleydp.com/understanding-claims-made-reported-professional-liability-policies/
- Commercial Insurance Claims Examples | AmTrust Financial, accessed August 16, 2025, https://amtrustfinancial.com/blog/agents/3-insurance-claims-scenarios-agent-should-share
- Occurrence vs. Claims Made Policies Explained – Insurance Training Center, accessed August 16, 2025, https://insurancetrainingcenter.com/resource/occurrence-vs-claims-made-policies-explained/
- Common insurance claim mistakes – Thimble, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.thimble.com/small-business-insurance/common-insurance-claim-issues
- Common Insurance Claim Mistakes To Avoid, accessed August 16, 2025, https://iastl.com/blog/common-insurance-claim-mistakes-to-avoid/
- 10 Crucial Mistakes to Avoid When Filing an Insurance Claim – CoverGo, accessed August 16, 2025, https://covergo.com/blog/10-mistakes-to-avoid-when-filing-insurance-claims/
- Ten Common Insurance Mistakes And How You May Be Able to Avoid Them, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.bbrown.com/us/insight/ten-common-insurance-mistakes-and-how-you-may-be-able-to-avoid-them/
- Failure To Report Claim Within Claims-Made-and-Reported Policy Period Bars Coverage, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.wiley.law/newsletter-3816
- Claims-Made Policies and the Notice-Prejudice Rule | Carlton Fields, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.carltonfields.com/insights/publications/2015/claims-made-policies-and-the-notice-prejudice-rule
- LATE IS ENOUGH – OR NOT: ANALYZING THE NOTICE-PREJUDICE RULE Charles Lemley and Kimberly Ashmore A BRIEF DISCUSSION OF THE NO, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.wiley.law/media/publication/413_2_late_is_enough_article-c_lemley_and_kashmore.authcheckdam.pdf
- Late Notice and the Prejudice Requirement | Saxe Doernberger & Vita, P.C., accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.sdvlaw.com/surveys/late-notice-and-the-prejudice-requirement/
- The Inapplicability of the Notice-Prejudice Rule to Pure Claims-Made Insurance Policies Note – Digital Commons @ UConn – University of Connecticut, accessed August 16, 2025, https://digitalcommons.lib.uconn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1046&context=law_review
- Please Excuse the Delay: The Consequences of Untimely Notice, Slow Investigation, and the Failure to Communicate – Duane Morris, accessed August 16, 2025, https://www.duanemorris.com/articles/static/evans_abainsurance_0312.pdf
