Table of Contents
“Why Can’t I Just Log In?” – Acknowledging the Homeowner’s Struggle
For many homeowners, managing insurance should be a straightforward task.
Yet, a common and deeply frustrating scenario unfolds for those holding what they believe to be a “Progressive” flood insurance policy.
A policyholder, needing to make a payment, download documents, or simply review their coverage, navigates to the main Progressive website.
They enter their login credentials—the same ones that work for their auto policy—only to be met with an error message or, more bewilderingly, a policy dashboard that shows no record of their flood coverage.
This experience often leads to a confusing journey through a maze of different company names like “ASI,” “Assurant,” or “Homesite,” multiple login pages, and a growing sense that a simple task has become inexplicably complex.
This feeling of confusion is not a user error; it is a predictable symptom of a convoluted but decipherable system.
The path to managing a Progressive-affiliated flood policy is fragmented due to a series of corporate acquisitions, federal programs, and a multi-faceted business model that prioritizes market reach over a unified customer experience.
This guide serves as a comprehensive map to that system.
It will not only provide the direct links and contact numbers needed to access and manage a policy but will also unravel the mystery behind the confusion.
By deconstructing the corporate relationships and technical frameworks at play, this report aims to transform a homeowner’s frustration into clarity and provide a definitive, step-by-step path to resolving any login or policy management issue.
Section 1: The Quick Answer: Your Direct Path to the Right Login Portal
For policyholders seeking an immediate solution, this section provides direct, actionable paths to the correct policy management portal.
The key to finding the right login is to identify the specific company that services the policy, which is not always Progressive itself.
The Three Main Doors to Your Policy
A “Progressive” flood insurance policy is almost always underwritten and serviced by a separate entity.
Think of Progressive as the storefront where the policy was purchased, but the actual management, billing, and claims processing happens in a different “workshop.” These workshops are the true destination for policy management.
The name of this servicing company is the most critical piece of information and can be found on policy declaration pages, bills, or other official correspondence.
The three most common “doors” lead to American Strategic Insurance (ASI), Assurant, or another third-party partner like Homesite.
The Login Decision Guide
To find the correct portal, a policyholder should examine their documents and answer a simple question: “What company name is listed on my flood insurance policy paperwork?”
- If the documents mention “American Strategic Insurance,” “ASI,” or “Progressive Home”: The policy is serviced by ASI, which is a Progressive-owned company.1 These policies use a separate login portal from the main Progressive.com website. The “Progressive Home” brand is the newer name for policies underwritten by the ASI group.3
- If the documents mention “Assurant”: Progressive acted as the agent that sold the policy, but Assurant is the company that underwrites and services it.4 Policyholders must use Assurant’s dedicated portal.
- If the documents mention “Homesite” or another partner name (e.g., “Taurus Flood”): Similar to the Assurant relationship, Progressive connected the homeowner with a third-party insurance partner. That partner is responsible for all servicing and has its own unique login system and customer service department.4
- If the documents only mention “Progressive”: While the primary login is Progressive.com, the system should redirect the user or provide information and links to the correct servicing partner once logged in. However, due to the system’s fragmentation, this is often where the confusion begins. Starting with the partner portals identified on the paperwork is typically more direct.
The following table provides a consolidated directory to bypass the initial confusion and go directly to the source.
Key Table 1: The Master Login and Customer Service Directory
| If Your Policy Documents Mention… | Your Servicing Company Is… | Primary Login Portal (URL) | Direct Customer Service Phone Number |
| American Strategic Insurance (ASI), Progressive Home | ASI (A Progressive Company) | portal.asipolicy.com or americanstrategic.com | 1-866-274-5677 4 |
| Assurant | Assurant | manage.myassurantpolicy.com | 1-800-358-0600 4 |
| Homesite | Homesite | homesite.com/OnlineServicing | 1-866-621-4823 4 |
| Taurus Flood | Taurus Flood | (Refer to policy documents) | 1-888-391-8533 4 |
| American Modern | American Modern | (Refer to policy documents) | 1-800-543-2644 4 |
| Nationwide | Nationwide | (Refer to policy documents) | 1-800-421-3535 4 |
| Foremost | Foremost | (Refer to policy documents) | 1-800-527-3907 4 |
Section 2: Deconstructing the Maze: The Hidden Corporate Story Behind Your Login Problem
The frustration experienced by policyholders is not arbitrary; it is the direct result of a complex and layered insurance ecosystem.
Understanding the corporate history and regulatory frameworks involved is the key to navigating it.
The confusion stems from three primary sources: a major corporate acquisition, a foundational government insurance program, and Progressive’s role as both a direct insurer and a marketplace for other companies.
The Event That Changed Everything: Progressive’s 2015 Acquisition of ASI
The root of the login problem for a majority of “Progressive” flood policyholders can be traced to April 1, 2015.
On that date, Progressive acquired a majority interest in ARX Holding Corp., the parent company of American Strategic Insurance (ASI).1
Progressive, a giant in auto insurance, made this move to aggressively compete in the “bundling” market, which allows customers to purchase home and auto insurance together.7
Prior to the acquisition, ASI was already a significant and independent force in property insurance, having issued its first flood policy back in 2000.1
It had its own established infrastructure, branding, customer service operations, and, critically, its own IT systems and login portals for policyholders and agents.8
Following the acquisition, ASI continued to operate as a largely separate company under its existing management, even as it became part of the “Progressive Group of Insurance Companies”.2
The IT systems and customer portals were never fully merged into the primary Progressive.com platform.
This strategic decision to maintain operational independence is the fundamental reason why a flood policy sold under the Progressive brand but serviced by ASI requires a separate login at an ASI-specific website.
Over time, ASI policies began to be marketed as “Progressive Home” products, adding another layer of branding that can obscure the underlying servicer.3
Therefore, a homeowner’s inability to find their ASI-backed flood policy on the main Progressive site is not a glitch but a legacy of this corporate structure.
The Government in Your Policy: Understanding the NFIP and “Write Your Own” (WYO)
The second layer of complexity comes from the federal government.
The vast majority of residential flood insurance policies in the United States are not traditional private insurance products.
They are part of the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), a federal initiative administered by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).10
To make these policies widely available, FEMA created the “Write Your Own” (WYO) program in 1983.12
The WYO program is a partnership that allows private insurance companies to sell and service federal flood insurance policies under their own brand names.
The private company handles the paperwork, billing, and claims processing, and in return, it receives an expense allowance from the government.
However, the federal government retains all the risk and is responsible for underwriting the losses.12
ASI is a prominent WYO provider.2
This means that when a homeowner buys a “Progressive Home” or “ASI” flood policy, they are most likely purchasing a standardized, government-backed NFIP policy.
The private company is acting as the administrator.
This has significant consequences for the policyholder.
The coverage limits (typically capped at $250,000 for the building and $100,000 for contents), policy terms, and premium rates are all set by the NFIP, not by Progressive or ASI.11
The branding is a mask for the product’s true nature.
The customer interacts with a private company, but the product itself is a public one, governed by federal regulations.
This explains why coverage terms can seem rigid and why the claims process may feel more bureaucratic than with other types of insurance.
Progressive as the “Matchmaker”: The Role of Assurant, Homesite, and Other Partners
The final piece of the puzzle is Progressive’s dual role in the market.
In addition to being a direct insurer through its ownership of subsidiaries like ASI, Progressive also operates as a massive independent insurance agency, sometimes referred to as the Progressive Advantage Agency, Inc..15
In this capacity, Progressive acts as a “matchmaker” or marketplace.
When a customer seeks a quote, if the best or only option in their area is not a product from a Progressive-owned company, Progressive will connect them with a third-party partner.13
This is a common arrangement for flood insurance, especially in certain regions.
Companies like Assurant, Homesite, and Taurus Flood are all distinct insurers that partner with Progressive.4
In these cases, Progressive’s role ends after the initial sale.
The third-party partner takes over completely, handling all billing, customer service, and claims.
These partners have their own entirely separate login portals, phone numbers, and internal processes.4
A policyholder who was matched with Assurant, for example, is an Assurant customer.
Their relationship with Progressive is purely historical.
This business model, which prioritizes offering a product in every market over a unified brand experience, is a primary driver of customer confusion.
The single “Progressive” name on the marketing materials obscures a complex web of different backend service providers, each with its own front door.
Section 3: A Practical Guide to Managing Your Flood Policy
Successfully logging into the correct portal is the first step.
The next is understanding the tools available and the nuances of the policy itself.
This section provides a practical overview of what policyholders can do online and what their flood coverage actually protects.
Navigating Your Policy Portal
While the visual design of the portals for ASI, Assurant, and Homesite may differ, they generally offer a core set of features that empower homeowners to manage their policies without needing to call customer service.
Based on the functionality described for these platforms, a user who has logged in can typically perform the following actions 16:
- Make Payments: View billing statements, make one-time payments, and manage automatic payment plans.
- View and Download Documents: Access and print critical documents, including the policy declarations page (which details coverage and limits), proof of insurance cards, and other notices.
- Report a Claim: Initiate the claims process online and, in some cases, monitor the status of an existing claim.
- Manage Policy Details: Update contact information such as mailing address, phone number, and email.
- Learn About Coverage: Access resources and frequently asked questions that explain policy coverage and deductibles.
Decoding Your Flood Coverage: What’s Actually Protected?
A frequent source of distress for homeowners comes after a flood, when they discover that their policy does not cover everything they assumed it would.
A standard NFIP policy, whether serviced by ASI or another WYO provider, has very specific and standardized coverage rules.13
What is Typically Covered:
- Building Structure: The insured building and its foundation, walls, and roof.
- Essential Systems: Electrical, plumbing, heating, and air conditioning systems.
- Built-in Items: Permanently installed carpeting, cabinets, and built-in appliances like refrigerators, stoves, and dishwashers.
- Detached Garage: Often covered up to 10% of the building coverage limit.5
- Debris Removal: The reasonable cost to remove debris from the insured property.
What is Typically NOT Covered (or has Limited Coverage):
- Basements and Below-Ground Areas: Coverage in basements is extremely limited. While essential systems like a furnace or water heater located there are covered, personal belongings (furniture, electronics) and finished elements like carpeting or drywall are generally not.13
- External Features: Damage to property outside the home, such as landscaping, trees, patios, decks, walkways, and swimming pools, is not covered.14
- Certain Water Damage: Damage from sewer or drain backups is excluded, though a separate “water back-up” endorsement can sometimes be added to a homeowners policy (not the flood policy) for this purpose.20
- Personal Property Value: A crucial distinction exists between Replacement Cost Value (RCV) and Actual Cash Value (ACV). RCV is the cost to replace a damaged item with a new one of similar kind and quality. ACV is the replacement cost minus depreciation for age and wear. While the home’s structure may be covered at RCV (if it’s a primary residence), personal belongings under a standard NFIP policy are almost always settled at their depreciated ACV.14 This means a homeowner will receive a check for what their five-year-old couch was worth, not what it costs to buy a new one.
- Additional Living Expenses: If a home is uninhabitable after a flood, the cost of temporary housing (like a hotel or rental) is not covered by an NFIP flood policy.21
The 30-Day Wait and Other “Fine Print”
Two other critical details of flood insurance are often overlooked.
First, most new flood policies are subject to a 30-day waiting period before coverage becomes effective.
This prevents individuals from purchasing a policy only when a hurricane is imminent.19
Second, the risk of flooding is not confined to coastal areas or riverbanks.
According to FEMA, between 20% and 25% of all flood insurance claims are filed by homeowners in low-to-moderate risk zones, underscoring the widespread nature of flood risk.13
Section 4: The Homeowner’s Troubleshooting Manual: When Logins and Links Fail
Even with the correct URL, technical glitches can prevent access to a policy portal.
User-generated reports from forums like Reddit provide a valuable, real-world guide to solving these problems when standard advice fails.
These issues are often not the user’s fault but are known system bugs.
“It’s Not You, It’s the System”: Solving Common Login Errors
Policyholders encountering login errors should know they are not alone.
The systems, particularly the main Progressive portal and its connections to subsidiary sites, have documented histories of glitches.
The following table codifies common problems and solutions that have proven effective for other users.
Key Table 2: Common Login Error Troubleshooting Guide
| Error / Symptom | Likely Cause (Based on User Reports) | Recommended Solution(s) | ||
| Login page spins indefinitely or returns a “504 Gateway Timeout” error.23 | A server-side configuration error or high traffic issue at Progressive/ASI. It can sometimes be related to the user’s specific network or internet service provider.23 | 1. Standard Steps: Clear browser cache and cookies.24 Try a different browser (e.g., Chrome, Firefox).25 | 2. Network Tricks: Turn off Wi-Fi on your phone and try logging in using cellular data.23 | 3. Advanced: Use a VPN to connect from a different geographic region, which can sometimes bypass the server issue.23 |
| The site says “incorrect password” even when the password is known to be correct.26 | A known glitch within the user account database where the stored password becomes desynchronized or corrupted, even if it appears correct in a password manager.24 | 1. Initiate Password Reset: Use the “Forgot Password” link.2. Expect the Unexpected: Be prepared for the password reset link to lead to a full account re-creation page instead of just a password change field. This appears to be the system’s unusual way of fixing the corrupted account link.24 | ||
| The password reset process forces you to create a whole new account, which seems redundant.24 | This is a flawed but functional “fix” for the “incorrect password” glitch. The system essentially creates a new, clean login profile and links it to your existing policy number, abandoning the corrupted old one.24 | Follow through with the new account creation process. Use your policy number and personal information as prompted. This unconventional method has been confirmed by multiple users as the solution to regain access.24 | ||
| The main Progressive website doesn’t show the flood policy, even after a successful login. | This is a feature, not a bug, of the fragmented system. The main Progressive site is primarily for its direct auto and other policies, not for policies serviced by ASI, Assurant, or Homesite.4 | Do not continue trying to find the policy on Progressive.com. Refer to your policy documents to identify the correct servicer (e.g., ASI, Assurant) and use the corresponding portal from the Master Login Directory in Section 1 of this guide. |
When to Escalate: Your Directory of Direct Phone Numbers
When all digital avenues are exhausted, the most effective solution is to call the servicing company directly.
User reports consistently show that a phone call can resolve issues that are impossible to fix online, such as correcting data errors or navigating complex claims.24
It is essential to call the number for the specific company that services the policy, not the general Progressive hotline.
Before calling, have the flood policy number ready.
This is the key piece of information the representative will need to access the correct account.
Direct Phone Numbers for Policy Service and Claims:
- ASI / Progressive Home: 1-866-274-5677
- Assurant: 1-800-358-0600
- Homesite: 1-866-621-4823
- Taurus Flood: 1-888-391-8533
- American Modern: 1-800-543-2644
- Nationwide: 1-800-421-3535
- Foremost: 1-800-527-3907
(Source for all numbers: 4)
Section 5: Conclusion: From Confusion to Clarity and Confidence
The path to managing a Progressive-affiliated flood insurance policy is undeniably, and often frustratingly, complex.
The initial struggle of a homeowner unable to perform a simple login is not an individual failure but a direct consequence of a layered and fragmented system.
The confusion is born from the strategic business decisions and historical events that shape the modern insurance landscape: the landmark 2015 acquisition of American Strategic Insurance by Progressive, the public-private framework of the National Flood Insurance Program’s “Write Your Own” model, and Progressive’s dual identity as both a direct insurer and a marketplace for third-party partners.
However, a system that is complex is not necessarily indecipherable.
By understanding this landscape, the homeowner’s experience can shift from one of confusion to one of control.
The knowledge that a “Progressive Home” policy is actually an ASI-serviced product, that the login portal is separate for a reason, and that an “Assurant” policy requires contacting Assurant directly provides a clear and actionable path forward.
The discovery that most policies are government-backed NFIP products demystifies the rigid coverage rules and claims processes.
Finally, the collection of real-world troubleshooting tactics provides a toolkit for overcoming the inevitable technical hurdles.
The homeowner who began this journey stymied by a login screen now possesses a map of the entire ecosystem.
They understand the key players, the hidden relationships, and the specific routes to take for any policy management need.
They are equipped with the correct URLs, the direct phone numbers, and the knowledge to navigate a system that was once an opaque maze.
The struggle was real, but it was not without a solution.
With this clarity, the homeowner is no longer just a customer; they are an informed and empowered stakeholder, fully in control of their policy.
Works cited
- ASI Progressive Insurance for Independent Agents, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.insuranceagencynetwork.com/asi-progressive.html
- American Strategic | Our Companies and Affiliations, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.americanstrategic.com/about-asi/our-companies-and-affiliations/
- Mergers & Acquisitions – the start of your Progressive journey, accessed August 13, 2025, https://aqn.foragentsonly.com/Merger/Merger
- Claims process for homeowners, renters, condo and manufactured home insurance, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/claims/property-process/
- Learn More About Flood Insurance, accessed August 13, 2025, https://homesite.com/flood-insurance/index.htm
- Progressive Insurance Acquiring Homeowners Group ASI for $875M, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2014/12/16/350221.htm
- American Strategic Insurance – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Strategic_Insurance
- Corporate Portal, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.americanstrategic.com/
- AmericanStrategic.com, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.americanstrategic.com/about-asi/
- Flood Insurance – Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, accessed August 13, 2025, https://floir.com/property-casualty/flood-insurance
- Best Flood Insurance Companies | LendingTree, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.lendingtree.com/home-insurance/best-flood-insurance/
- Write Your Own Flood Insurance Company List, accessed August 13, 2025, https://agents.floodsmart.gov/topics/writing-policies/wyo-insurance-companies
- Flood Insurance Quote – Progressive, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/flood-insurance/
- What Does Flood Insurance Cover? – Progressive, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/answers/flood-101/
- Progressive Insurance Review 2025 | Bankrate, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/reviews/progressive/
- Login – Manage My Policy, accessed August 13, 2025, https://manage.myassurantpolicy.com/
- Manage Your Policy – Homesite Insurance, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.homesite.com/OnlineServicing/Welcome.aspx
- Log In & Manage Your Policy – Progressive, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/manage-policy/
- Get a Flood Insurance Quote Now! | GEICO, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.geico.com/flood-insurance/
- Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Water Damage? – Progressive, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/answers/does-home-insurance-cover-water-damage/
- Can Renters Get Flood Insurance? | Progressive, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/answers/flood-insurance-for-renters/
- Is My House in a Flood Zone? – Progressive, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/answers/am-i-in-a-flood-zone/
- cannot log in to progressive.com : r/Progressiveinsurance – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Progressiveinsurance/comments/1m03l6y/cannot_log_in_to_progressivecom/
- Unable to use website. Been like this for a month : r/Progressiveinsurance – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Progressiveinsurance/comments/1j9mulu/unable_to_use_website_been_like_this_for_a_month/
- Technical Help | Progressive, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/help/
- Cannot log in; site says “incorrect password” even after changing password : r/help – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/help/comments/gaygkb/cannot_log_in_site_says_incorrect_password_even/
- The idiocy of Progressive Insurance – Reddit, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Insurance/comments/1bqf8a5/the_idiocy_of_progressive_insurance/
