Finding the American “National Insurance”: A Journey Through the U.S. Social Safety Workshop

Introduction: The Ghost in the Machine

I’ll never forget the meeting.

It was early in my career as a financial advisor specializing in transatlantic relocations.

My new client, a sharp executive from Manchester, sat across from me, full of confidence.

“Right,” he said, sliding a folder across the table, “let’s map out my National Insurance contributions and benefits here in the States.

I need to understand how it all translates.” I smiled, equally confident.

“Of course,” I replied, “we’ll get a clear picture of the U.S. equivalent.”

What followed was a week of professional humiliation.

I searched for the American “Department of National Insurance,” a single, unified agency that handled pensions, healthcare funding, and unemployment.

It didn’t exist.

My search for a simple, coherent system devolved into a nightmarish descent into an alphabet soup of acronyms: SSA, OASDI, FICA, SECA, CMS, DOL.

I found not one system, but a bewildering array of disconnected federal programs, state-level variations, and private-sector entanglements.¹

The advice I eventually gave my client was a patchwork of caveats and confusion, a far cry from the clarity he expected and deserved.

That failure was a painful but necessary catalyst.

It forced me to abandon the search for a single entity and instead embark on a journey to understand why the American system was so fundamentally different.

It was a journey that led me to an epiphany, a new way of seeing that I now share with all my clients.

The core problem, I discovered, is the question itself.

Asking for the U.S. equivalent of “National Insurance” is like asking for the steering wheel on a train.

The query presupposes a design that simply isn’t there.

The American system is not a single, cohesive vehicle.

To understand it, you must first discard the notion of a unified blueprint and instead, step into a place of organized, historical chaos: a sprawling, century-old workshop.

Part I: The Epiphany – It’s Not a Building, It’s a Workshop

My breakthrough came from the world of systems thinking.

The U.S. social safety net is not a master-planned skyscraper, designed and built all at once like the UK’s post-war National Insurance system.

It is a vast, rambling Community Workshop.

Imagine a large plot of land.

In the 1930s, facing the crisis of the Great Depression, a group of foremen led by Franklin d+. Roosevelt built the first, largest shed to address elderly poverty and unemployment.⁴

Decades later, in the prosperous 1960s, a new foreman, Lyndon B.

Johnson, saw a different problem—a lack of healthcare for seniors—and added a large medical wing.⁵

Over the years, other structures were added to solve specific problems.

Each shed was built with different materials, funded by different membership dues, and requires a different key for entry.

Each has its own rulebook, often written in a different decade with different assumptions.

This “Workshop” analogy is not just a convenient metaphor; it is a direct representation of the system’s history and structure.

The fragmentation you see today is a fossil record of its evolution.

The system wasn’t designed; it accreted.

It grew in response to distinct historical crises and political movements, from the New Deal to the Great Society.⁷

To understand this complex, you cannot look for a single front door.

You must take a guided tour, shed by shed, to understand what each tool is for, who can use it, and how it’s paid for.

Part II: The Main Workshop – The Social Security Administration (SSA)

The largest and oldest part of the complex is the main workshop, run by the Social Security Administration (SSA).

This is where the primary tools for income replacement are kept.

Its existence is rooted in a core American philosophy: these are not handouts, but an “earned right” based on a lifetime of work and contributions.¹

This contrasts sharply with the UK’s more collectivist approach, which aims to provide a basic, flat-rate poverty-protection floor for everyone.⁹

This philosophical divergence explains why the American system is earnings-related, rewarding higher lifetime contributions with higher benefits, a concept we will explore in detail.

Tool Shed 1: The Retirement Pension Plan (OASDI)

The cornerstone of the SSA’s workshop is the Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance (OASDI) program, which for most Americans is simply “Social Security”.⁴

Its primary function is to provide a continuing stream of income to replace, in part, earnings lost due to retirement.

Eligibility: Earning Your Workshop Access

Access to this shed isn’t automatic; it must be earned.

The system operates on “credits” (also known as quarters of coverage).

As you work and pay Social Security taxes, you earn these credits.

In 2025, for instance, you earn one credit for each $1,810 in earnings, up to a maximum of four credits per year.¹¹

To become “fully insured” for retirement benefits, most people need to accumulate 40 credits, which translates to roughly 10 years of work over their lifetime.¹

This 10-year requirement is a critical threshold for anyone planning a career in the United States, especially for expatriates who may split their working years between countries.

Benefit Calculation: An Earnings-Based System

Unlike the UK’s flat-rate state pension, where everyone with enough qualifying years gets the same base amount, the U.S. Social Security benefit is directly and powerfully linked to your lifetime earnings.⁹

The SSA calculates your benefit by:

1. Taking your earnings for each year of your career.
2. Adjusting those earnings for inflation (indexing them to today’s wages).
3. Identifying the 35 years with the highest indexed earnings.
4. Averaging these 35 years of earnings to get your “Average Indexed Monthly Earnings” (AIME).
5. Applying a progressive formula to your AIME to determine your “Primary Insurance Amount” (PIA), which is your full monthly benefit amount.

This earnings-based model means that higher lifetime earnings result in higher benefits.¹¹

The difference can be staggering.

For a high-earning couple who both paid the maximum Social Security tax throughout their careers, the combined annual benefit can top $96,000.

This is two to three times more than the maximum state pension a similar couple would receive in the UK, Canada, or Australia, where the benefit is designed as a more modest, universal safety Net.⁹

Retirement Age: When Can You Claim?

The U.S. system offers flexibility in when you can start drawing benefits, but with significant trade-offs.

• Full Retirement Age (FRA): This is the age at which you are entitled to 100% of your earned benefit. The FRA used to be 65, but it has been gradually increasing. For those born in 1960 or later, the FRA is 67.¹¹
• Early Retirement: You can choose to start receiving benefits as early as age 62. However, your benefit will be permanently reduced. For someone with an FRA of 67, starting at 62 results in a 30% reduction in their monthly payment.⁴
• Delayed Retirement: For every year you delay taking benefits past your FRA, up to age 70, your benefit permanently increases by about 8% per year. Delaying from an FRA of 67 to age 70 results in a benefit that is 24% higher than your full amount.¹²

Tool Shed 2: The Disability & Survivor’s Forge (SSDI & Survivors Benefits)

The OASDI program is more than just retirement.

It also houses crucial insurance functions for disability and death, protecting workers and their families throughout their careers.

• Disability Insurance (SSDI): This provides income support to individuals who are unable to work because of a severe, long-term medical condition that is expected to last at least one year or result in death.¹³ The eligibility test for SSDI is stricter than for retirement. A worker must not only be “fully insured” but also meet a “recent work test,” which generally requires them to have worked for 5 of the last 10 years before their disability began.¹
• Survivors Benefits: This is a vital but often overlooked part of the system. If a worker who has earned enough Social Security credits dies, benefits may be paid to their family members. This includes surviving spouses (including divorced spouses), children under 18, and in some cases, dependent parents.¹ For many young families, Social Security is their primary life insurance policy; about 98% of children and their surviving parents are eligible for benefits if a working parent dies.¹

Funding the Workshop: FICA & SECA Membership Dues

This entire workshop is not funded by general government revenue.

It is a self-contained social insurance system financed by dedicated payroll taxes, which function like mandatory membership dues.

• The Mechanism: The funding comes from the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) for employees and the Self-Employed Contributions Act (SECA) for self-employed individuals.¹⁴ These taxes are automatically deducted from paychecks or paid with quarterly estimated taxes.
• The Rates & The Cap: The FICA tax is a combination of two separate taxes for two different programs:

1. Social Security (OASDI): The tax rate is 12.4%. For employees, this is split evenly: 6.2% is paid by the employee, and 6.2% is paid by the employer. Self-employed individuals pay the full 12.4%.¹⁶
2. Medicare (Hospital Insurance): The tax rate is 2.9%, also split evenly between employee and employer (1.45% each). Self-employed individuals pay the full 2.9%.¹⁶

A critical feature is the Social Security wage base limit.

In 2024, this limit is $168,600, and it is projected to rise to $176,100 in 2025.⁴

This means that earnings above this amount are not subject to the 6.2% Social Security tax.

This cap is a key detail for high-earning professionals and a major point of political debate regarding the program’s long-term funding.

• The Trust Funds: These tax revenues are directed into two main trust funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund and the Disability Insurance (DI) Trust Fund.⁴ The system largely operates on a pay-as-you-go basis, meaning that contributions from today’s workers are used to pay benefits to current retirees and other beneficiaries. Any excess funds are invested in special U.S. government bonds.¹⁹

The table below provides a clear summary of the payroll taxes a worker in the U.S. can expect to pay.

Tax Component	Employee Rate	Employer Rate	Total Self-Employed Rate	2025 Wage Base Limit
Social Security (OASDI)	6.2%	6.2%	12.4%	$176,100
Medicare (HI)	1.45%	1.45%	2.9%	None
Additional Medicare Tax	0.9%	0%	0.9%	On earnings over $200,000 (single) / $250,000 (joint)
Total	7.65% + 0.9% on high earnings	7.65%	15.3% + 0.9% on high earnings

Source: ⁴

Part III: The Health & Medical Wing

A common point of confusion for those accustomed to a unified system like the UK’s National Insurance is that in the U.S. workshop, healthcare is handled in entirely separate sheds with different funding streams, rules, and even philosophies.

In the UK, National Insurance contributions help fund the National Health Service (NHS), creating an integrated system for both income and health.²¹

In the U.S., the systems are siloed.

Social Security is for income; Medicare and Medicaid are for health.

This fundamental split is a primary driver of the system’s complexity and a major departure from the model many non-Americans expect.

Tool Shed 3: Medicare – The Health Plan for Seniors & the Disabled

Medicare is a federal health insurance program.

It is crucial to understand that it is not universal health care for all Americans.

It is specifically for people aged 65 or older, certain younger people with long-term disabilities, and individuals with End-Stage Renal Disease.⁶

Funding Medicare

Medicare is funded differently from Social Security.

It has its own dedicated payroll tax of 1.45% from the employee and 1.45% from the employer (for a total of 2.9%), which is also part of the FICA deduction.¹⁶

Unlike the Social Security tax, there is

no wage cap on the Medicare tax; it applies to all of a worker’s earnings.

Furthermore, high-income earners pay an “Additional Medicare Tax” of 0.9% on earnings above certain thresholds ($200,000 for single filers).¹⁶

Other parts of the program are funded by monthly premiums paid by beneficiaries and general government revenues.

The Four Parts of Medicare

The Medicare program itself is fragmented into four distinct parts, each covering different services and with its own cost structure.

This is a notorious source of confusion for beneficiaries.

• Part A (Hospital Insurance): This part helps cover inpatient care in hospitals, skilled nursing facility care (following a hospital stay), hospice care, and some home health care.⁶ For most people who have worked and paid Medicare taxes for at least 10 years, Part A is premium-free.²²
• Part B (Medical Insurance): This covers medically necessary doctor’s services, outpatient care, preventative services, and durable medical equipment.⁶ Part B is not free; beneficiaries must pay a monthly premium, which can be higher for those with higher incomes.²²
• Part C (Medicare Advantage): These are private health plans (like HMOs or PPOs) that are offered as an alternative to “Original Medicare” (Parts A and B). By law, they must cover everything that Original Medicare covers, but they often bundle in additional benefits like dental, vision, and prescription drug coverage (Part D). These plans are run by private insurance companies approved by Medicare.⁶
• Part D (Prescription Drug Coverage): This is optional coverage that helps pay for prescription drugs. It is offered through private insurance companies either as a standalone plan (to supplement Original Medicare) or as part of a Medicare Advantage (Part C) plan. Beneficiaries pay a separate monthly premium for this coverage.⁶

The following table provides a simplified guide to decoding the parts of Medicare.

Part	Common Name	What It Covers	How You Pay
Part A	Hospital Insurance	Inpatient hospital stays, skilled nursing facilities, hospice care	Mostly premium-free for those with a qualifying work history.
Part B	Medical Insurance	Doctor visits, outpatient care, preventive services, medical supplies	Monthly premium (income-adjusted).
Part C	Medicare Advantage	An all-in-one alternative to Original Medicare; bundles Parts A, B, and often D.	Monthly premium (in addition to the Part B premium).
Part D	Prescription Drug Coverage	Prescription drugs.	Optional; separate monthly premium (income-adjusted).

Source: ⁶

Tool Shed 4: Medicaid – The Needs-Based Community Clinic

Separate from both Social Security and Medicare is Medicaid.

If Medicare is the health plan for seniors, Medicaid is the health coverage program for low-income Americans.

It is a means-tested program, meaning eligibility is based on income and resources, not on work history.²⁴

Federal-State Partnership and Variation

Medicaid is a joint federal and state program.

The federal government sets broad guidelines, but each state designs and administers its own version of the program.²⁷

This partnership model leads to immense variation across the country.

Eligibility rules, covered services, and provider payment rates can differ dramatically from one state to another, making it impossible to speak of a single “Medicaid” program in the U.S..²⁶

Interaction with Medicare: “Dual Eligibility”

The fragmentation of the health wing becomes most apparent for low-income seniors who qualify for both Medicare and Medicaid.

These individuals are known as “dual eligibles”.²⁴

For them:

• Medicare is the primary payer: It pays first for covered health services.
• Medicaid is the secondary payer: It acts as a supplemental policy, covering costs that Medicare doesn’t, such as Part B premiums, deductibles, and coinsurance. Critically, Medicaid also covers services that Medicare largely does not, most notably long-term care in a nursing home.²⁴

Navigating this dual system requires interacting with multiple, non-integrated federal and state bureaucracies—a clear demonstration of the challenges created by the workshop’s siloed design.

Part IV: The Annexes – Specialized & Temporary Support

Beyond the main workshop and its medical wing lie smaller, more specialized sheds.

The most prominent of these is for unemployment support, and it serves as the ultimate example of the system’s fragmentation.

Tool Shed 5: Unemployment Insurance – The State-Level Emergency Kits

Unemployment Insurance (UI) provides temporary, partial income replacement to workers who have lost their jobs through no fault of their own, such as a layoff.²

It was established as part of the original Social Security Act of 1935, but its implementation is unique.

Extreme Fragmentation by Design

While Social Security and Medicare are federal programs with uniform rules nationwide, UI is a joint federal-state program that tilts heavily toward state control.

The result is not one system, but over 50 distinct UI systems—one for each state, the District of Columbia, and several territories.²

This extreme fragmentation is a direct product of American federalism, the constitutional principle of shared power between the national and state governments.

For the individual, this means that where you live and work determines everything about your unemployment benefits:

• Benefit Amounts: The maximum weekly benefit varies wildly, from a low of $235 in Mississippi to a high of $1,015 in Massachusetts as of 2022.²
• Duration: Most states offer up to 26 weeks of benefits, but this can change, especially during economic downturns when the federal government may fund extensions.
• Eligibility Rules: Each state sets its own requirements for past earnings (the “base period”) and the specific reasons for job loss that qualify for benefits.²⁹
• Application Process: Each state has its own agency and application portal, with different procedures and timelines.²⁹

For anyone seeking to understand “national insurance,” the reality of UI is perhaps the most disorienting feature.

It reveals that the system’s fragmentation is not just programmatic but deeply geographical and political.

The workshop analogy must be expanded: it’s not one workshop, but a central headquarters with over 50 affiliated, independently-run franchises, each with its own local rulebook and set of tools.

Funding and General Eligibility

UI is funded almost entirely by payroll taxes paid by employers at both the federal (FUTA) and state (SUTA) levels.²

While eligibility rules vary, they generally require that a worker:

1. Has lost their job through no fault of their own (e.g., not fired for misconduct or quit without good cause).
2. Meets the state’s minimum requirements for wages earned or time worked in a “base period” (usually the first four of the last five calendar quarters).
3. Is able, available, and actively seeking work.²

Part V: A Guide for Outsiders – Navigating the Workshop

For an expatriate, immigrant, or global HR manager, understanding the individual sheds is only half the battle.

The real challenge is navigating the entire complex, especially when your mental map is based on a completely different design.

This section provides a practical guide, comparing the U.S. workshop to its UK counterpart and offering specific advice for non-citizens.

Comparing Workshops: The U.S. System vs. The UK System

The differences between the two systems are not merely administrative; they are philosophical.

The U.S. approach is rooted in individualism and an earnings-based “earned right,” while the UK system is built on a more collectivist ideal of a universal safety Net.⁹

This core distinction gives rise to vastly different structures and outcomes.

Feature	United States System	United Kingdom System
Core Philosophy	Individualistic, “earned right.” Benefits are tied to lifetime earnings. 1	Collectivist, “social solidarity.” Provides a flat-rate pension floor for all qualifiers. 9
Structure	Fragmented. Separate programs for retirement/disability (Social Security), health (Medicare/Medicaid), and unemployment (state-run). 1	Unified. National Insurance (NI) contributions fund the State Pension, some welfare benefits, and help fund the National Health Service (NHS). 21
Retirement Benefit	Earnings-related. Can be very generous for high earners but less of a backstop for low earners. 9	Flat-rate. Provides a more equal, but generally lower, baseline pension for everyone. 9
Health Care Link	Separate. Medicare is a distinct program for seniors/disabled, funded by a separate payroll tax and premiums. Medicaid is a means-tested program. 22	Integrated. NI contributions help fund the comprehensive, universal National Health Service (NHS), available to all residents. 21
Unemployment	State-run. Over 50 different systems with varying rules and benefit levels. 2	National. A single, nationwide system for unemployment benefits (e.g., Jobseeker’s Allowance).
Voluntary Contributions	Not possible. You cannot make voluntary contributions to improve your U.S. Social Security record. 12	Possible. Individuals can often make voluntary NI contributions to fill gaps in their record. 12

Source: ¹

Special Access Keys: The Totalization Agreement

For individuals who work in both the U.S. and the UK (and a few dozen other countries), a critical tool exists to bridge the two systems: the Totalization Agreement.¹²

This bilateral treaty serves two crucial functions:

1. Eliminates Double Taxation: It ensures that a worker pays social security taxes to only one country at a time on the same earnings. Generally, if you are sent by a U.S. employer to work in the UK for five years or less, you continue to pay only U.S. Social Security taxes.¹²
2. Combines Work Credits: It allows you to combine your work credits from both countries to meet the minimum eligibility requirements for a pension. For example, if you have 6 years of work in the U.S. and 4 years in the UK, you would not meet the 10-year minimum for either country’s pension alone. Under the agreement, you can “totalize” these periods to meet the 10-year threshold and then receive a pro-rated pension from both countries based on the contributions you made to each.¹²

The Immigrant’s & Expat’s Guidebook: A Workshop with a Strict Security System

For non-U.S. citizens, the social safety workshop often feels less like a supportive community resource and more like a high-security facility with a complex and unforgiving set of rules.

The conventional “safety net” metaphor breaks down; for many immigrants, the system is an obstacle course filled with hidden traps and gates.³⁷

Getting a Key (The Social Security Number)

The Social Security Number (SSN) is the master key to working and paying taxes in the U.S. For non-citizens, obtaining one can be a confusing process.

• Before Arrival: Many individuals can apply for an SSN as part of their immigrant visa application with the U.S. Department of State.³⁹
• After Arrival: If you are lawfully present and authorized to work, you can apply at a Social Security office. This requires presenting original documents, such as your unexpired foreign passport and your U.S. immigration documents (e.g., Form I-551 “Green Card” or Form I-766 “Employment Authorization Document”).³⁹ It is a free service, but all documents must be originals or certified copies.³⁹

Eligibility Rules & Traps

Navigating eligibility is fraught with peril.

A misstep can lead to denial of benefits or even jeopardize one’s immigration status.

• “Qualified Alien” Status: This is a specific legal term under immigration law. To be eligible for most federal means-tested benefits, like Supplemental Security Income (SSI), a non-citizen must first fit into one of the “qualified alien” categories (e.g., Lawful Permanent Resident, refugee, asylee).⁴⁰
• The Five-Year Wait: A major hurdle for many Lawful Permanent Residents (“green card” holders) is that they are barred from receiving many federal benefits, including Medicaid and SSI, for the first five years after obtaining their qualified status, even if they are working and paying taxes.⁴⁰
• The “Public Charge” Fear: The “public charge” rule is one of the most significant barriers. U.S. immigration law allows the government to deny a green card application if an individual is deemed “likely at any time to become a public charge,” meaning primarily dependent on the government for subsistence.⁴³ The fear that using public benefits like Medicaid or food assistance could be used against them in a future immigration proceeding causes many eligible immigrant families to avoid programs they desperately need and are legally entitled to.⁴⁰ This fear, as one immigrant advocate described it, creates a barrier “far greater than that posed by language difference”.⁴⁵
• The Contribution-Benefit Inequity: Undocumented immigrants, while ineligible for Social Security benefits, often work in jobs where employers deduct FICA taxes. This has created a situation where millions of unauthorized workers contribute billions of dollars to the Social Security and Medicare trust funds each year with no prospect of ever receiving benefits, effectively subsidizing the system for others.⁴⁶

Receiving Benefits Abroad

For non-U.S. citizens who qualify for and begin receiving Social Security benefits, moving outside the U.S. triggers another complex set of rules.

• The Six-Month Rule: Payments are generally stopped after a non-citizen has been outside the U.S. for six full, consecutive calendar months. To restart payments, they must return and remain in the U.S. for a full calendar month.⁵⁰
• Country Restrictions: The U.S. Treasury Department prohibits sending payments to certain countries, such as Cuba and North Korea. The SSA has its own list of restricted countries (including several former Soviet republics) where payments are generally withheld unless specific exceptions are met.⁵⁰
• “Proof of Life” Questionnaires: The SSA periodically sends questionnaires to beneficiaries living abroad to verify their continued eligibility. Failure to return this form promptly can result in the suspension of benefits.⁵¹

Part VI: The Future of the Workshop – Cracks, Renovations, and Radical Redesigns

The U.S. Social Safety Workshop, built over nearly a century, is showing its age.

The demographic and economic assumptions of the past no longer hold, leading to intense political debates about its future.

The tools are getting rusty, and the foundation has cracks.

The Solvency Debate: A Looming Deadline

The core problem is one of simple arithmetic.

Due to a combination of factors—retiring Baby Boomers, longer life expectancies, and lower birth rates—fewer workers are paying into the system relative to the number of beneficiaries drawing from it.⁴⁸

According to the official Trustees’ Reports, the trust funds that pay for Social Security retirement benefits (OASI) and Medicare’s hospital insurance (Part A) are projected to become depleted in the early 2030s.⁵³

It is critical to understand what “insolvency” means.

It does not mean the programs will be bankrupt or have zero money.

It means that ongoing tax revenues will no longer be sufficient to pay 100% of promised benefits.

If Congress fails to act, the law mandates an automatic, across-the-board benefit cut.

Projections suggest this would be a reduction of around 17-24% for Social Security and 11% for Medicare Part A payments, a devastating outcome for millions of reliant seniors.⁵³

Two Sets of Blueprints: The Political Divide on Repairs

The looming solvency crisis has become a major political battleground, with the two main parties offering fundamentally different blueprints for repair, rooted in their core philosophies about the role of government.

• Liberal/Democratic Proposals (Reinforce the Collective): These plans focus primarily on increasing revenue to meet the promised obligations. Key proposals include:

• Raising or Eliminating the Social Security Wage Cap: This would require high earners to pay Social Security taxes on all of their income, not just up to the annual limit. This single change could close a large portion of the long-term funding gap.⁵⁵
• Increasing the Payroll Tax Rate: A modest increase in the 12.4% FICA tax rate, phased in over time, is another common proposal.⁵⁵
• Expanding Benefits: Some proposals couple tax increases with benefit expansions, arguing that the system should be strengthened, not just preserved.⁵⁷
• Conservative/Republican Proposals (Promote Individual Responsibility): These plans focus on reducing long-term expenditures or restructuring the system to lessen reliance on the government. Key proposals include:

• Raising the Full Retirement Age: Gradually increasing the FRA to 69 or 70 to reflect longer life expectancies.⁵⁶
• Modifying the Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA): Using a different measure of inflation (like the “chained CPI”) that typically grows more slowly, which would reduce the annual growth of benefits over time.⁵⁶
• Partial Privatization: Allowing workers to divert a portion of their payroll taxes into private investment accounts, shifting some of the risk and potential reward to the individual.⁵⁶

Tear It Down and Start Over? The “Medicare for All” Debate

While the solvency debate focuses on renovating the existing workshop, a more radical proposal is on the table for the health and medical wing: demolishing it entirely and building a modern skyscraper in its place.

This is the essence of the “Medicare for All” debate.

“Medicare for All” is a term for a single-payer healthcare system.

Under such a plan, the government would replace the fragmented mess of private insurance, employer plans, Medicare, and Medicaid with a single, comprehensive public insurance program for all Americans.⁵⁸

• Arguments For: Proponents argue that a single-payer system would finally achieve universal coverage, eliminate premiums and deductibles, drastically reduce administrative waste, and give the government powerful leverage to negotiate lower prices for drugs and medical services.⁵⁸ It would, in effect, create the kind of unified, national health program that many non-Americans assume the U.S. should have.
• Arguments Against: Opponents warn that it would require massive tax increases, force over 150 million Americans off their existing employer-sponsored plans, stifle innovation, and lead to government rationing of care and long wait times for procedures.⁵⁸

This debate goes to the heart of the American identity crisis over healthcare, pitting the ideal of universal access against a deep-seated preference for market-based solutions and a distrust of large-scale government programs.

It is the ultimate expression of the choice between renovating the old, fragmented workshop or undertaking a complete, and controversial, rebuild.

Conclusion: Your Personal Map to the Workshop

My journey, which began with the embarrassing failure to find a simple answer for my client, ended with a profound realization.

The key to understanding the American social safety net was not to find a non-existent unified system, but to embrace its complexity and see it for what it is: a historical workshop, built piece by piece over a century of crises and compromises.

This “Community Workshop” paradigm is more than an analogy; it is a functional map.

It explains the fragmentation, the philosophical divides, and the practical challenges of navigation.

It clarifies why Social Security is an earned pension, why Medicare is a separate health plan for seniors, why Medicaid is a needs-based state-run program, and why Unemployment Insurance is a patchwork of 50 different systems.

You, the reader, now possess this map.

You understand that there is no single “National Insurance” in the USA.

You know that the system’s structure is a record of its history, reflecting a nation’s ongoing, often contentious, debate about the balance between individual responsibility and collective security.

Armed with this knowledge, you are no longer lost in the fog of acronyms and disconnected rules.

You are equipped to ask the right questions, identify the right tools, and confidently navigate this uniquely American complex.

The feeling of being lost can now be replaced by the confidence of a skilled navigator who holds the blueprint.

Works cited

1. Social Security Programs in the United States – Social Insurance …, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/progdesc/sspus/social-insurance-programs.html
2. Unemployment insurance in the United States – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment_insurance_in_the_United_States
3. Fragmented Democracy – Log In, accessed August 13, 2025, https://inside.ccsi.org/CCSIPortal/media/content/PDFs/Fragmented-Democracy.pdf
4. Social Security (United States) – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_(United_States)
5. The US social welfare structure has been shaped both by – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/history/pdf/histdev.pdf
6. Medicare (United States) – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicare_(United_States)
7. A History of Welfare Policy in the United States: To Feed or Blame the Hungry?, accessed August 13, 2025, https://trace.tennessee.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3174&context=utk_chanhonoproj
8. Major Welfare Changes and Public Opinion, 1965-2010 – Xavier University, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.xavier.edu/xjop/documents/vol6_2015/1XJOPVolVI2015MajorWelfareChangesandPublicOpinion.pdf
9. Social Security Pays Excessive Benefits to the Highest-Income Earners: A UK Comparison, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.cato.org/blog/social-security-pays-excessive-benefits-highest-income-earners-uk-comparison
10. www.ssa.gov, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/progdesc/sspus/social-insurance-programs.html#:~:text=The%20OASDI%20program%E2%80%94which%20for,retirement%2C%20disability%2C%20or%20death.
11. Understanding the Benefits – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10024.pdf
12. US and UK Social Security Benefits – MASECO Private Wealth, accessed August 13, 2025, https://masecoprivatewealth.com/wp-content/uploads/2025-01/US-UK-Social-Security-Benefits.pdf
13. Social Security Administration – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Administration
14. en.wikipedia.org, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Insurance_Contributions_Act
15. What are FICA and SECA taxes? | Frequently Asked Questions – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/faqs/en/questions/KA-02375.html
16. Topic no. 751, Social Security and Medicare withholding rates | Internal Revenue Service, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc751
17. What Is FICA Tax? 2025 Rates and How It’s Calculated – Paycom, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.paycom.com/resources/blog/fica-tax/
18. FICA Tax: What Does It Mean and How Is It Calculated in 2025? – Paychex, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.paychex.com/articles/payroll-taxes/how-to-calculate-fica-rate
19. What is FICA? – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/people/materials/pdfs/EN-05-10297.pdf
20. How Social Security Retirement Benefits Work – YouTube, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CU3QR2eIj0
21. National Insurance Contributions for US Expats (Guidelines), accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.expattaxonline.com/national-insurance-contributions-for-us-expats/
22. Medicare – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10043.pdf
23. www.medicare.gov, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.medicare.gov/about-us#:~:text=Medicare%20is%20health%20insurance%20for,their%20health%20coverage%20from%20Medicare.
24. Medicaid | Medicare, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.medicare.gov/basics/costs/help/medicaid
25. www.medicare.gov, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.medicare.gov/basics/costs/help/medicaid#:~:text=Medicaid%20is%20a%20joint%20federal,medical%20costs%20for%20other%20adults.
26. Medicaid | Medicaid, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid
27. Medicaid – Health, United States – CDC, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/hus/sources-definitions/medicaid.htm
28. Medicaid – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicaid
29. How Do I File for Unemployment Insurance? | U.S. Department of …, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/unemployment-insurance
30. Unemployment Benefits – EDD – CA.gov, accessed August 13, 2025, https://edd.ca.gov/en/unemployment/
31. Apply for Unemployment Benefits – Texas Workforce Commission, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.twc.texas.gov/services/apply-benefits
32. Individualism vs. Collectivism: Exploring the Duality of American Values – ActivateGenZ, accessed August 13, 2025, https://activategenz.org/learnbitez/blog-post-title-two-47tw6
33. Pensions: international comparisons – The House of Commons Library – UK Parliament, accessed August 13, 2025, https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn00290/
34. United-States – Pensions and Benefits – Canada.ca, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.canada.ca/en/services/benefits/publicpensions/cpp/cpp-international/united-states.html
35. Taxes in the UK vs. US: The Full Breakdown | Bright!Tax Expat Tax Services, accessed August 13, 2025, https://brighttax.com/blog/taxes-in-uk-vs-us/
36. Social Security Benefits for Noncitizens – Congress.gov, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/RL32004
37. The Antisocial “Safety Net” – PMC, accessed August 13, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8361565/
38. Gaps in the Safety Net Metaphor – AMA Journal of Ethics, accessed August 13, 2025, https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/gaps-safety-net-metaphor/2010-06
39. Social Security Numbers For Noncitizens, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10096.pdf
40. 5 Key Facts About Immigrants and Medicaid – KFF, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.kff.org/racial-equity-and-health-policy/issue-brief/5-key-facts-about-immigrants-and-medicaid/
41. SSI Spotlight on SSI Benefits for Noncitizens | Supplemental … – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/ssi/spotlights/spot-non-citizens.htm
42. Health and Health Care Experiences of Immigrants: The 2023 KFF/LA Times Survey of Immigrants | KFF, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.kff.org/racial-equity-and-health-policy/issue-brief/health-and-health-care-experiences-of-immigrants-the-2023-kff-la-times-survey-of-immigrants/
43. Public Charge Resources | USCIS, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.uscis.gov/green-card/green-card-processes-and-procedures/public-charge/public-charge-resources
44. A-310, General Policy | Texas Health and Human Services, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.hhs.texas.gov/handbooks/texas-works-handbook/a-310-general-policy
45. Asking for Care, Not Favors: Experience of Immigrants in the US Medical System, accessed August 13, 2025, https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/asking-care-not-favors-experience-immigrants-us-medical-system/2008-04
46. Immigrants and Retirement Resources – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v74n1/v74n1p27.html
47. The Social Security Insolvency Crisis: How Deportation Makes It Worse, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/blog/social-security-crisis-how-deportation-makes-it-worse/
48. The Truth about Immigrants, Medicare, and Social Security – Center for Retirement Research, accessed August 13, 2025, https://crr.bc.edu/the-truth-about-immigrants-medicare-and-social-security/
49. Misinformation vs. Immigrant Experiences Using Health Insurance and Other Programs | KFF, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.kff.org/quick-take/misinformation-vs-immigrant-experiences-using-health-insurance-and-other-programs/
50. Your Payments While You are Outside the United States – SSA, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10137.pdf
51. Can a Non-U.S. Citizen Spouse Get Social Security Benefits?, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.greenbacktaxservices.com/blog/social-security-will-non-us-spouse-lose-benefits/
52. Getting Social Security benefits if you are living outside the U.S. | USAGov, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.usa.gov/social-security-abroad
53. Social Security Predicted to Run Out of Money Sooner Due to Trump Bill – Newsweek, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.newsweek.com/social-security-retirement-savings-benefits-money-2110258
54. Event Recap: Checking in on the 2025 Social Security & Medicare Trust Funds, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.crfb.org/blogs/event-recap-checking-2025-social-security-medicare-trust-funds
55. Fixing Social Security – Brookings Institution, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/fixing-social-security-blueprint-for-a-bipartisan-solution/
56. Social Security debate in the United States – Wikipedia, accessed August 13, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_debate_in_the_United_States
57. Proposals to Change Social Security, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.ssa.gov/oact/solvency/index.html
58. Medicare for All: What Is It and How Will It Work? – Healthline, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.healthline.com/health/what-medicare-for-all-would-look-like-in-america
59. Medicare-for-All Is Not Medicare, and Not Really for All. So What Does It Actually Mean? – ProPublica, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.propublica.org/article/medicare-for-all-is-not-medicare-and-not-really-for-all-so-what-does-it-actually-mean
60. Universal Health Care | Pros, Cons, Debate, Arguments, Medicare, Medicaid, & Insurance | Britannica, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.britannica.com/procon/universal-health-care-debate
61. 6 Things to Know About Sen. Bernie Sanders’ Medicare for All Proposal – Wharton, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.wharton.upenn.edu/story/6-things-to-know-about-sen-bernie-sanders-medicare-for-all-proposal/
62. Is It time for Medicare for All? – Open to Debate, accessed August 13, 2025, https://opentodebate.org/debate/replace-private-insurance-medicare-all/
63. What Does “Medicare for All” Really Mean? – YouTube, accessed August 13, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hQV4SZic0lE